← Back to Events

Interior Secretary Zinke Recommends Reducing Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument ↳ Part of Series

📅 August 24, 2017
📍 Washington, D.C.
Tags: Biodiversity Bureau of Land Management Congress Department of the Interior Executive Action Legal Challenge Monument Reduction Pacific Northwest Timber/Logging
Inclusion Criteria: Executive Review or Recommendation
At a Glance
📰 3 Sources
👥 5 People
Key individuals: Ryan Zinke, Donald Trump

Description

Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke submitted formal recommendations to President Trump on August 24, 2017, proposing boundary reductions for Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument in southern Oregon. The recommendations followed an administrative review of 27 national monuments designated or expanded since 1996 under the Antiquities Act. Despite the proposal, the Trump administration never implemented changes to this monument, leaving its expanded boundaries intact. Documents leaked in September 2017 revealed that Zinke's report specifically advocated removing approximately 40,000 acres of Oregon and California Revested Lands from monument protection to "allow sustained-yield timber production" under the 1937 O&C Act. This recommendation directly challenged President Obama's January 2017 expansion of the monument, which had increased protections for a biodiverse convergence zone where the Cascade, Siskiyou, and Klamath mountain ranges meet. The American Forest Resources Council had already filed suit against the expansion, arguing that Congress had mandated those particular lands for timber harvest rather than preservation. Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum immediately threatened legal action if the administration attempted implementation, asserting that neither the President nor the Interior Secretary possessed statutory authority under the Antiquities Act or Federal Land Policy and Management Act to unilaterally diminish monument designations. Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson pledged support for potential litigation. The scientific community rallied behind the expanded boundaries, with more than 200 researchers signing letters supporting the monument's protection, while the public comment period generated 242,000 comments favoring the expanded boundaries. Zinke's recommendations also targeted Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments in Utah for significant reductions. The Trump administration acted on those Utah monuments in December 2017, substantially shrinking their boundaries. However, Cascade-Siskiyou remained untouched throughout Trump's presidency, leaving both the expanded monument boundaries and the unresolved legal questions about presidential reduction authority in place for this particular site. President Clinton had originally designated the monument in 2000 as the first national monument specifically established to protect biological diversity.

🔗 Related Events

Part of
📂 The Evolution and Legal Defense of Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument (2000–2024)
June 9, 2000
Also in this series (4)
Clinton Designates Cascade-Siskiyou as First National Monument Created to Protect Biodiversity Jun 9, 2000
President Obama Expands Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument via Proclamation 9564 Jan 12, 2017
Timber Industry Files Lawsuits Challenging Cascade-Siskiyou Monument Expansion Mar 1, 2017
Supreme Court Declines to Hear Cascade-Siskiyou Monument Cases, Ending Legal Challenges Mar 25, 2024

Sources (3)

Source: Other
Date: August 24, 2017
Read full article → https://www.opb.org/news/article/cascade-siskiyou-monument-shrink-zinke-interior-recommend/
People Mentioned (3)
Author 1
👤 Ryan Zinke primary Author
U.S. Secretary of the Interior at Department of the Interior
As Interior Secretary, he led the administrative review of national monuments and authored the recommendations to President Trump proposing boundary modifications to Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument.
Mentioned 2
👤 Donald J. Trump primary Mentioned
President of the United States at U.S. Government
As President, he initiated the review of national monuments and received Secretary Zinke's recommendations regarding Cascade-Siskiyou, although he ultimately did not implement the proposed reduction for this monument.
👤 Ellen Rosenblum secondary Mentioned
Oregon Attorney General at Oregon Department of Justice
As Oregon Attorney General, she immediately threatened legal action against any attempt to reduce the Cascade-Siskiyou National Monument, asserting the President's lack of authority to do so.
Source: Other
Date: August 24, 2017
Read full article → https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/merkley-wyden-respond-to-trump-administration-assault-on-cascade-siskiyou-national-monument
People Mentioned (2)
Quoted 2
👤 Jeff Merkley secondary Quoted
U.S. Senator for Oregon at U.S. Senate
As a U.S. Senator for Oregon, he issued a press release opposing the recommendation to shrink the monument, emphasizing local community input and legal concerns.
👤 Ron Wyden secondary Quoted
U.S. Senator for Oregon at U.S. Senate
As a U.S. Senator for Oregon, he issued a press release opposing the recommendation to shrink the monument, highlighting widespread public support for its expanded boundaries.
📋

Why This Event Is Included

Executive Review or Recommendation
EXECUTIVE_REVIEW
definitive
Administrative reviews, secretarial recommendations, or executive branch assessments of monument status.
Curator's Justification
This event definitively qualifies as an executive review and secretarial recommendation. Interior Secretary Zinke conducted a formal administrative review of 27 national monuments and submitted written recommendations to President Trump on August 24, 2017. The criterion description explicitly states 'Administrative reviews, secretarial recommendations, or executive branch assessments of monument status' with examples including 'Interior Secretary monument reviews; agency recommendations to president.' This event IS the recommendation itself, distinguishing it from implemented boundary changes (which would require BOUNDARY_CHANGE criterion) or legal proceedings (which were threatened but contingent responses, not the primary event).

Found an error or have additional information?

Help us maintain accuracy by submitting a challenge to this event.

🚩 Challenge This Event